| A
Promising Look At The Future
Through
the eyes of children, Justine Shapiro's Oscar-nominated documentary
has earned international praise for its moving and honest look
at the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Boston
[03.19.02] -- For decades, the
war between Israelis and Palestinians has shaped the day-to-day
lives of thousands of people in the Middle East. The violence
has continued, leaving many experts predicting a bleak future
for the region. But an award-winning documentary by Tufts graduate
Justine
Shapiro indicates that Israelis and Palestinians still have
reason for hope -- their children.
"There
has never been a more crucial time for a closer look at the war
between Israelis and Palestinians, and no film in recent memory
has offered such poignant insight into the Middle East conflict,
as this portrait of ordinary kids growing up amid violence and
strife," reported The Boston Globe.
Co-directed
by Shapiro -- a 1985 Tufts graduate and host of the Travel Channel's
"Lonely Planet" -- "Promises"
captures the Israeli-Palestinian conflict from the perspective
of seven children
-- ages 9-13 --who live on opposite sides of Israel's security
checkpoints.
"An
intensely personal and insightful documentary... ["Promises"]
demonstrates the unusual power of thoughtful, subjective filmmaking,"
reported the New York Times. "This extraordinary enterprise
was distilled from 170 hours of filming between 1997 and the summer
of 2000."
Often
overlooked, the region's children offered Shapiro and her colleagues
unique and startlingly honest viewpoints on the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict.
"A
lot of people questioned our decision to focus on children so
young," Shapiro told New York's Daily News. "But we knew
they could express their feelings articulately and originally,
fusing what they absorbed from their parents with their own experiences
and spirit. They liked that we respected them enough to ask them
hard questions."
Their
comments often reflected the starkness and depth of the emotions
that fuel the ongoing battles.
"We
fight because this land is ours," says Moishe Bar Am, one of the
Jewish boys interviewed for the film. " If I could make my future,
all the Arabs would fly away. The Jews would stay and the temples
would be rebuilt ... We have our Army to protect us. We have our
firing range. And if the soldiers aim poorly, it's okay because
they might shoot an Arab."
Mahmoud
-- a Palestinian boy who was also interviewed -- provides his
own perspective.
"This
is my land," Mahmoud says. "I was born and raised here, You have
no right to take it. I support Hamas and Hezbollah. They kill
women and children, but they do it for their country. The more
Jews we kill, the fewer there will be -- until they're almost
gone."
The
film's power, reported the Jerusalem Post, comes from the
intersection of the children's hardened political views with their
seemingly typical lives as kids.
"Though
the political declarations that come out of the children's mouths
are often distressing for their programmatic nature, we also seem
glimmers of hope," reported the Post.
"One
of the most bizarrely uplifting scenes in the film comes, for
instance, when an articulate [Jewish boy] talks earnestly ...
about his relationships to his Arab neighbors," reported the newspaper.
"As they discuss this topic with great seriousness, a group of
Palestinian boys gather around, curious about the camera, and
one of them commences a burping contest with the Jewish kid. Strange
as it sounds, the sight of these two little boys -- ostensible
enemies, with no common language -- belching gleefully at one
another offers more cause for optimism than do a whole parade
of Tenets, and Mitchells and Zinnis."
The
recipient of numerous international film awards, Shapiro's unique
approach for "Promises'" is very powerful.
"We
didn't want it to be about current events -- that's not going
to open people's hearts," Shapiro told the Globe. "We wanted
audiences to develop relationships with these kids, and that meant
showing more facets of these kids than their earnestness and their
political wisdom."
The
approach appears to have worked well.
In
its debut at the Rotterdam Film Festival in the Netherlands, "Promises"
became the first documentary to win top honors in the festival's
30-year history. The Tufts graduate's work has since added another
dozen or so awards, including an Oscar nomination -- which "Promises"
is expected to win.
And
critics around the world have praised "Promises" for everything
from its brutal honesty to its insightful approach.
"Good
documentary films reveal what is under the surface of a situation
or a person," Shapiro said in an interview with PBS.
"It is the process of unearthing these complexities that motivates
me. Ultimately, I believe that life is all about learning something
more about oneself and the world around us."
In
an interview with the Globe, Shapiro added, "["Promises"]
makes people rethink the capacity of young kids to express themselves
and be impacted by their environment."
Photos
by Justine Shapiro and Meagan Shapiro.
|